Rooted in Reason: Nurturing the Seeds of Liberty


Going Broke for the Degree by grassroothawaii
July 12, 2011, 5:03 pm
Filed under: Education | Tags: , ,

By Cannon Brooke

It seems universities are making a considerable amount of the headlines today, however, this publicity is conspicuously disparaging. Some topics covered by the media examine the problem on campuses with binge and underage drinking, athletic scandals and the occasional student riot. But there is one topic that stands out – the burgeoning cost of a post-secondary education.

We all have heard the promises of holding a college degree, a life of intellectual fulfillment, and a substantially much higher income than non-degree holders. Going to college is viewed as a stepping-stone into adulthood, “a small price to pay” argue universities, for a quality education. Even politicians weigh in on this topic, some going as far as to say “on average you will earn a million dollars more with a bachelors degree than just having a high school diploma” (Hillary Clinton) over a life time.

However, with a tumultuous economy and student debt out-pacing credit card debt, the college experience is having many concluding that it just might be a scam.

A fundamental reason for the explosive tuition hike in recent years is the lack of productivity in universities. The efficiency of university personnel has been stagnating in recent years. So the question arises: how come the rest of the economy can become more proficient, utilize the latest technology to lower costs, while the universities on the other hand, need more administrators and professors to educate a given number of students?

And that is just the problem. Universities are NOT subject to the same market-based principles and are subject to the inefficiencies of the current non-profit and vague ownership model. Deans, presidents and other faculty have no incentives to lower the costs of attending a university since it is mostly taxpayer and donor funded. There is absolutely no accountability in academia. Also, all of the subsidies that the schools receive abate competition and reduce the market-imposed discipline to economize and innovate, leading to higher tuition costs.

The post-secondary education, particularly at the larger universities, is notoriously resistant to any kind of reform – and this is not a just few recalcitrant professors. Tenured faculty inordinately resists any change to the status quo and will veto proposals affecting their workload or opulence. This policy is further perpetuated by presidents placating constituencies [donors] and faulty unions by continuing lumbering decision procedures and other impediments to change – consequently, stifling innovation.

Universities often lure professors into their institutions by promising reduced workloads and extended sabbaticals so instructors can “research” and work on publication. This is typical in research universities. A focus on publishing and not instructing leads to undergraduate students feeling neglected, since emphasis is put on having their faculty publish in some obscure scholarly journal that nobody reads. As a consequence of this focus on “research,” a decline in teaching loads has occurred and the number of academic journals has multiplied.[1] Focusing on research and publishing in academic journals does not promote enhanced student learning, instead, subsequently drives up the cost of tuition and lowers the actual classroom time.

Low retention rates, declining analytical competency and years of debt are making some question the real worth of a college degree. With the cost of obtaining a four-year degree more than doubling since 1975 in inflation-adjusted dollars, there is no question as to why some are looking towards alternatives to this latest bubble that is certainly going to pop.[2]

I have written a working paper on the alternatives to college available on the Grassroot Institute’s website. The paper goes deeper into the problem with higher education and calls for a more pragmatic approach to post-secondary education. Please check it out and let me know what you think.

The link can be found here.

 

Sources:

 

[1] Vedder, R. K. (2004). Going broke by degree : why college costs too much. Washington, D.C., AEI Press.

[2]  Digest of Educational Statistics. 2009a. Table 26. Expenditures of educational institutions related to the gross domestic product, by level of institution: Selected years, 1929-30 through 2008-09. National Center for Education Statistics.

Advertisements

1 Comment so far
Leave a comment

This is a thoughtful and excellent article, but it misses the real cause of the exploding burdensome debt of a college education now imposed upon students and parents – the recent availability of very large student loans for virtually any student who applies. This policy mirrors the one that banks used to inflate the real estate bubble (particularly in the last 10 years) before the big crash.

The goal is to get everyone into debt, paying more and more interest to the banks, requiring everyone to focus on their everyday needs, instead of thinking about and gaining an understanding of the criminal nature of both the government and the banking system. Wage slaves are very easy to control.

Everyone is encouraged to watch one of the best documentary films at The Freedom Information Center, a free service of Awake and Aware Hawai`i, Hawai`i’s newest political party.

The College Conspiracy
Web site: http://www.AAAFreedom.com
Pass Code: 2011-HawaiiOhana
Enter Video Code: 07-education2

Wake up and become aware of the truth!
http://www.AwakeAndAwareHawaii.org

Comment by Mike Higgins




Leave a Reply (Comments are approved by a moderator before they are posted.)

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s



%d bloggers like this: