Rooted in Reason: Nurturing the Seeds of Liberty

An “F” for Freedom by maliab
June 8, 2011, 5:13 pm
Filed under: Hawaii Sunshine, Limited Government | Tags: , , ,

By Malia Hill

George Mason University has released its 50-state Freedom Index, which grades the individual states on individual and economic liberty (albeit with a decided political view of individual liberty that some might take issue with, especially as it regards legalization of drugs and same-sex partnerships).  Aside from those controversial matters, however, the Freedom Index includes a strong overview of market freedoms and threats to liberty in each state that takes into account everything from taxation and red tape for businesses to homeschool regulations.  So . . . how did Hawaii measure up?

As anyone who has noticed our state government’s near-passion for red tape and regulation might have guessed  . . . not well.  Hawaii came it at number 47 overall (and number 46 in economic freedom).  If it’s any consolation, that’s a +2 change from the 2007 ranking.  So now, we’re only the fourth least free state in the country.  (For the curious, this means we beat out California, New Jersey, and New York, but were edged out by Massachusetts.)  Some highlights from the Mercatus analysis of Hawaii:

On the spending side, the state is highly fiscally centralized due to its unique statewide school system, but despite being freed from the burden of paying for schools, local governments have to raise over 80 percent of their funds through own-source taxes, the highest figure in the country. Sales, individual income, and motorvehicle-license taxes are high. Gun laws are among the worst in the country . . . . Hawaii has the second strictest gambling laws in the country, after Utah. . . . Educational regulation is excessive, with private schools having to obtain state approval to operate, significant homeschool regulations, and school attendance mandated through age 18. . . . On labor law the state government is interventionist, with a prevailing-wage law, strict workers’ compensation requirements, mandatory short-term disability insurance, and a state occupational safety and health agency. Hawaii has not reformed eminent domain, and the state liability system is far below average. . . .

Among the reforms that the report recommends Hawaii adopt to advance freedom in the state are eliminating the state’s restrictions on private schools (which raises interesting questions about how this might affect our seemingly unending battles over Hawaii’s public schools–and what parents might prefer) and reforming eminent domain to protect against private-to-private property transfers as part of blight reform.  (This is a widespread response to the controversial Supreme Court decision that gave local governments shockingly broad eminent domain powers–including the power to seize private property and award it to another private entity as part of a plan to “economically revitalize” the community.)


2 Comments so far
Leave a comment

I’m not surprised, but it still makes me depressed. Why can’t these politicians and bureaucrat find some self control instead of trying to control us? They not only need to stop making more regulations, they need to repeal them.

Comment by David Singhiser

Not surprising, we are last, or first, depending on perspective, in many categories: highest rent, highest taxes,highest % of state workers, highest meth use, worse drivers and roads, poor public school graduation rates, ugliest airport, etc. This is what 1 party rule does to a state.

Comment by jim quimby

Leave a Reply (Comments are approved by a moderator before they are posted.)

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: