Rooted in Reason: Nurturing the Seeds of Liberty

Where Pensions Meet Transparency by maliab
April 20, 2011, 6:20 pm
Filed under: Economy, Hawaii Sunshine | Tags: , , ,

Rich Danker is quickly becoming a nationally recognized expert on the pension crises facing so many states and municipalities.  (Yes, Hawaii isn’t alone in its slow march towards pension disaster, though we do have the somewhat dubious distinction of being one of the most critical cases.)  As he outlines in the first article of a three-part series on the pension problem, there’s an interesting connection between lack of transparency and unfunded pension liability–the bad accounting that helps to cover up the seriousness of the problem and handicaps reform efforts.  Of course, we’re no strangers to questionable accounting either, which suggests that Hawaii’s citizens should be demanding greater transparency from those who administer the state pension system:

How do you solve a fiscal crisis if you don’t have the right numbers? That is the dilemma facing governors, legislators and would-be reformers around the country trying to deal with the public employee pension crisis.

Faulty accounting practices stipulated by the Government Accounting Standards Board have allowed state retirement systems to dramatically underestimate their pension deficits. In most states, the trustees of these funds have not provided the right data or even agreed to release it. This cover-up stands in the way of designing the reforms needed to fix the most serious calamity facing state and local finances.

A pension deficit is the shortfall between a fund’s assets and liabilities. The amount needed to pay benefits in the future is discounted to determine how much money needs to be set aside today. GASB instructs pension funds to discount their liabilities using the expected return on their assets; in other words, how well they expect their investments to perform.

But these pensions are defined benefits, not defined contributions, and so their return is conceived as a risk-free guarantee rather than an investment return like a 401(k). The right discount rate is a risk-free rate of return such as the yield off a U.S. Treasury note.

What’s the difference between discounting liabilities using an 8 percent rate of return projection and a 3.5 percent risk-free Treasury rate? Trillions of dollars in pension debt. Thanks to studies done by experts such as Andrew Biggs of the American Enterprise Institute and Joshua Rauh of Northwestern University, we have estimates for the true values of the unfunded pension liabilities using the risk-free discount rate.

In a report published a year ago, Biggs calculated that by mid-2008 the states’ collective unfunded pension liabilities exceeded $3 trillion. The state pension funds reported $438 billion at the time.

This projection gap is the difference between a pension problem and a pension crisis, as Frank Keegan of put it. How severe is the crisis? Biggs calculated in the same report that the average pension plan has only a 16 percent probability of being able to pay off its liabilities as presently constructed. Incremental reforms will not fix this picture. States need to remake their pension systems by restructuring benefits and switching to the defined contribution method of compensation.

Working with several states on these proposals, I’ve seen firsthand how faulty accounting and missing data are getting in the way of real pension reform. Legislators and executive officials don’t have the proper unfunded liability projections from the retirement system, don’t get any data from it at all, or don’t even get their phone calls returned. Without the right numbers, they can’t draft the legislation needed to overhaul public pensions in their states.


Leave a Comment so far
Leave a comment

Leave a Reply (Comments are approved by a moderator before they are posted.)

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: